
Santa Monica Proper Hotel
Best for travelers who want a lively Santa Monica location, the only rooftop pool on the Westside, strong wellness programming, and easy walking access to the Pier and Third Street Promenade.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Santa Monica Proper Hotel is a 5-star, design-forward coastal luxury hotel in central Santa Monica with the area's only rooftop pool and an Ayurvedic Surya Spa; read this if you want a walkable Santa Monica base with wellness programming and rooftop dining. Malibu Beach Inn is a 4.5-star oceanfront Malibu hotel on Carbon Beach and Malibu Pier — read this if you prefer beachfront rooms, private beach access, and a quieter coastal escape up the PCH.
Updated · about 16 miles (≈26 km) apart

Best for travelers who want a lively Santa Monica location, the only rooftop pool on the Westside, strong wellness programming, and easy walking access to the Pier and Third Street Promenade.

Best for guests who want true beachfront rooms with private balconies, direct access to Malibu Pier and Carbon Beach, and a quieter, seaside Malibu experience.
When Santa Monica Proper Hotel wins: pick Proper when you want to be in the heart of Santa Monica — close to shopping, the Pier and beach bike paths — with a large design-forward hotel, a prominent rooftop pool, and an extensive wellness program (Surya Spa, Recovery Suite, 24/7 fitness).
When Malibu Beach Inn wins: choose Malibu Beach Inn when your priority is being on the sand — rooms with private balconies and ocean views, a private beach, and a smaller, more intimate hotel footprint steps from Malibu Pier and Carbon Beach.
Bottom line: Proper is the better option for an active, amenity-rich Santa Monica stay (rooftop pool, big spa, event space); Malibu Beach Inn is the better choice for a quieter, seaside Malibu getaway with direct beachfront access and oceanfront rooms.
| Category | Santa Monica Proper Hotel | Malibu Beach Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, design-led urban coastal hotel with wellness focus | Smaller, luxury oceanfront beach hotel |
| Location | Downtown Santa Monica; ~0.4 miles (8-min walk) to Santa Monica State Beach and near Third Street Promenade | Eastern Malibu on Pacific Coast Hwy; steps from Malibu Lagoon State Beach and a 3-min walk to Malibu Pier |
| Size (rooms) | 262 rooms and suites | 47 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 (must show photo ID and credit card) | All ages welcome; not adults-only |
| Pools / beach | City’s only rooftop pool (5,165 SF) — guest-only hours 8am–sundown | On private beach; hotel highlights private beach and beach amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | Calabra (rooftop Mediterranean–Californian) + Palma lobby lounge | Carbon Beach Club restaurant and 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | Surya Spa (Ayurvedic treatments, signature Abhyanga + Shirodhara, Recovery Suite) and 24/7 fitness center with classes | Full-service spa offering facials and massage; fitness and classes listed on site |
| Known for | Rooftop pool, Kelly Wearstler design, large event space and wellness programs | Oceanfront rooms with balconies, private beach access, proximity to Malibu Pier |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking (fee), free bicycles, close to Big Blue Bus and Metro E Line access in Santa Monica | Valet parking (surcharge), secured parking and covered options listed |
| Room features | Design-focused rooms with wellness amenities (15 room types listed) | Rooms often include balconies, fireplaces, minibars, espresso makers and Frette sheets (room types listed as supplier) |
| Size of meeting/event spaces | Extensive — multiple ballrooms and ~16,000–24,000+ sq ft of event/meeting space | Two meeting rooms; smaller event footprint |
Santa Monica Proper sits in downtown Santa Monica, a short walk from the Pier, Third Street Promenade and beach.
Best if you want walkable access to Santa Monica’s central attractions and transit connections.
Malibu Beach Inn is an oceanfront hotel on Pacific Coast Highway within steps of Malibu Pier and Carbon Beach.
Best if you prioritize being directly on the sand and near Malibu Pier rather than in a busy downtown area.
Proper has 262 rooms and suites finished with layered textures and wellness-minded design.
Choose Proper for a wide range of room types and design-led interiors in a larger hotel.
Malibu Beach Inn has 47 individually decorated guestrooms, many with private balconies and ocean views.
Choose Malibu Beach Inn for intimate, ocean-facing rooms and private balconies right over the sand.
Santa Monica Proper centers dining around Calabra rooftop and the Palma lobby lounge.
Proper is for rooftop dining with city and ocean views plus a lobby lounge for all-day bites.
Malibu Beach Inn’s signature on-site restaurant is Carbon Beach Club with 24-hour room service available.
Malibu Beach Inn focuses on beachfront dining and in-room service for a low-key seaside meal experience.
Proper’s standout amenity is the Westside’s only rooftop pool deck with a rooftop bar and cabanas.
Proper is centered on a large rooftop pool experience tied to Calabra and city/ocean views.
Malibu Beach Inn’s signature advantage is private beach access and direct shoreline proximity.
Malibu Beach Inn is focused on beachfront access and seaside rooms rather than a rooftop pool feature.
Proper emphasizes wellness with Surya Spa, a Recovery Suite, a 24/7 fitness center and complimentary classes.
Proper is the choice for structured spa programs, bigger fitness facilities and active wellness offerings.
Malibu Beach Inn offers a full-service spa and on-site fitness options in a quieter, seaside setting.
Malibu Beach Inn suits guests looking for straightforward spa treatments and ocean-focused outdoor activities.

Santa Monica Proper — only rooftop pool on the Westside, rooftop dining and a central Santa Monica location.

Malibu Beach Inn — oceanfront rooms with private balconies and immediate access to Malibu Pier and Carbon Beach.

Santa Monica Proper — Surya Spa, Recovery Suite and a large 24/7 fitness center with classes.

Malibu Beach Inn — smaller property footprint and private beach make for a lower-key coastal escape.
Santa Monica Proper Hotel is closer — about an 8–10 minute walk to the Pier and a short walk to the Third Street Promenade.
Malibu Beach Inn has private beach access and is steps from Malibu Pier and Malibu Lagoon State Beach; Santa Monica Proper is a short walk from Santa Monica Beach but not beachfront.
Both hotels welcome guests of all ages. Santa Monica Proper has a minimum check-in age of 21 for the guest registering the room; Malibu Beach Inn is not adults-only.
Santa Monica Proper emphasizes wellness with Surya Spa, an extensive Recovery Suite and a 24/7 fitness center with classes; Malibu Beach Inn offers a full-service spa but on a smaller scale.
Explore how Santa Monica Proper Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·